Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss RAM Price Fixing Lawsuit

Even if you've been under a rock all year, it's hard to ignore the massive RAM crisis that's been going on since late 2025. And while prices likely won't improve, it does seem like there's a small possibility that the three major RAM manufacturers might face some accountability. A class action lawsuit accusing Micron, SK Hynix, and Samsung of colluding to fix the price of RAM while simultaneously scaling back production was filed back in June. This kind of case will likely take years to go through the system. But the RAM companies filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that each company made "rational choices consistent with their own independent self interest" and that the case was just a "rerun" of a similar case from 2022. But on Friday, Judge Noël Wise denied the motion. Wise's order references the previous case, which was dismissed, saying, "During the hearing, Defendants quoted the late Honorable Judge Posner who famously wrote, '[c]ompetitors in concentrated markets watch each other like hawks.'" But then added, "But Plaintiffs’ allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do." Now, before you go and celebrate that RAM prices are going to come crashing down, this order simply means that the case will move forward – the fight isn't over yet. This class action lawsuit will probably be moving through the courts for a couple years before any final decision is made. While the previous 2022 class action was dismissed, the three companies named in this lawsuit do have a history of working together to manipulate the RAM market. All the way back in 2002, the U.S. Department of Justice investigated a "criminal cartel" made up of Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron in order to fix prices. That investigation ended in jail time for a Samsung executive, along with a $300 million fine for Samsung and a $185 million fine for SK Hynix. If anything, though, the RAM market is worse for consumers than either of the two times that the three RAM companies have been accused of price fixing. According to the order, the last class action came after memory prices spiked by 165% in 2018. But compared to 2026, that's nothing. The order says, "In sum, Plaintiffs allege a 697% price increase for conventional DRAM over an eighteen-month period." Looking at RAM kits on Amazon, it's hard to deny that number. Only time will tell how this lawsuit will play out, but no matter what happens, it doesn't seem like RAM prices are going to improve any time soon. Samsung told investors during its latest earnings call that "AI-driven demand [is] likely to further tighten supply shortages" next year. That was after all three memory manufacturers reported selling through their 2027 manufacturing capacity all the way back in August 2026. It's no wonder that Xbox Project Helix is rumored to hit $1,800.

Nov 16, 2026 - 21:00
 4
Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss RAM Price Fixing Lawsuit
Even if you've been under a rock all year, it's hard to ignore the massive RAM crisis that's been going on since late 2025. And while prices likely won't improve, it does seem like there's a small possibility that the three major RAM manufacturers might face some accountability.

A class action lawsuit accusing Micron, SK Hynix, and Samsung of colluding to fix the price of RAM while simultaneously scaling back production was filed back in June. This kind of case will likely take years to go through the system. But the RAM companies filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that each company made "rational choices consistent with their own independent self interest" and that the case was just a "rerun" of a similar case from 2022. But on Friday, Judge Noël Wise denied the motion.

Wise's order references the previous case, which was dismissed, saying, "During the hearing, Defendants quoted the late Honorable Judge Posner who famously wrote, '[c]ompetitors in concentrated markets watch each other like hawks.'" But then added, "But Plaintiffs’ allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation – an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."

Now, before you go and celebrate that RAM prices are going to come crashing down, this order simply means that the case will move forward – the fight isn't over yet. This class action lawsuit will probably be moving through the courts for a couple years before any final decision is made.

While the previous 2022 class action was dismissed, the three companies named in this lawsuit do have a history of working together to manipulate the RAM market. All the way back in 2002, the U.S. Department of Justice investigated a "criminal cartel" made up of Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron in order to fix prices. That investigation ended in jail time for a Samsung executive, along with a $300 million fine for Samsung and a $185 million fine for SK Hynix.

If anything, though, the RAM market is worse for consumers than either of the two times that the three RAM companies have been accused of price fixing. According to the order, the last class action came after memory prices spiked by 165% in 2018. But compared to 2026, that's nothing. The order says, "In sum, Plaintiffs allege a 697% price increase for conventional DRAM over an eighteen-month period." Looking at RAM kits on Amazon, it's hard to deny that number.

Only time will tell how this lawsuit will play out, but no matter what happens, it doesn't seem like RAM prices are going to improve any time soon. Samsung told investors during its latest earnings call that "AI-driven demand [is] likely to further tighten supply shortages" next year. That was after all three memory manufacturers reported selling through their 2027 manufacturing capacity all the way back in August 2026. It's no wonder that Xbox Project Helix is rumored to hit $1,800.



Jat AI Stay informed with the latest in artificial intelligence. Jat AI News Portal is your go-to source for AI trends, breakthroughs, and industry analysis. Connect with the community of technologists and business professionals shaping the future.